DineSpin

Best Fine Dining in New York

Find the best fine dining restaurants in New York, NY. Scored on what actually matters.

By DineSpin Team·Updated February 2026·10 spots

New York fine dining is crowded, expensive, and mostly fine—until you sit down at one of these places and remember why the city's reputation is earned. The ten restaurants below represent the current state of the game: some are institutions (Blue Ribbon, Craft), some are newer and still proving themselves (Elia's), and some have figured out how to do upscale right without the pretense. A few have real problems that matter. Most don't.

Recommended:

Best Fine Dining in New York

1.

Kappo Sono

95/100

Kappo Sono offers an excellent and unforgettable Kaiseki dining experience, characterized by meticulously crafted seasonal dishes, impeccable service, and a beautiful, curated atmosphere. It is highly recommended for special occasions and those seeking a journey through Japanese cuisine.

Pro tip: An unforgettable night at Kappo Sono! If you’re craving an elevated kaiseki journey, this spot is unbeatable.

🍽️Food100

The food is consistently described as outstanding, with diners highlighting the seasonal ingredients, meticulous preparation, and the overall journey of flavors.

An absolutely stunning meal

👋Service95

Service is well-regarded as friendly, professional, and attentive, contributing to a special and welcoming dining experience.

Service was very good

Vibe95

The atmosphere is consistently described as beautiful, special, and elegant, with a sense of ceremony and curated ambiance.

Beautiful dining room

💰Value85

While not explicitly detailed, the high recognition for the quality and experience suggests good value for the price, particularly for special occasions.

Best Kaiseki experience

📍 39 E 13th St 6th Floor, New York, NY 10003, United States
5$$$$New YorkJapanese
Ideal for
Special occasions and celebrationsDiners seeking an elevated Kaiseki experienceFood enthusiasts appreciating seasonal ingredients
2.

Il Tinello

95/100

Il Tinello is a well-regarded Midtown Italian restaurant celebrated for its excellent food, outstanding service, and charming atmosphere. It consistently delivers a memorable dining experience, making it a top choice for special occasions and regular visits.

Pro tip: One of the best dining experiences we've had in NY.

🍽️Food98

The food is well-regarded for its outstanding taste, authentic Italian preparation, and high-quality ingredients, with many dishes highlighted as standouts.

Food was spectacular, authentic Italian dishes

👋Service97

Service is frequently described as outstanding, attentive, friendly, and professional, with specific staff members like Ray and Benny receiving repeated commendations.

Staff were very friendly and extremely attentive

Vibe92

The atmosphere is consistently lauded as charming, cozy, elegant, and vibrant, contributing to a memorable dining experience.

Atmosphere was electric

💰Value85

While prices are noted as reasonable for the quality, some diners found portions to be small, impacting perceived value.

Portions were small

📍 244 E 46th St, New York, NY 10017, United States
4.9$$$New YorkItalian
Ideal for
Special occasions and celebrationsDiners seeking authentic Italian cuisineThose who appreciate attentive, personalized service
3.

Luthun

95/100

Luthun offers an excellent and highly creative tasting menu experience, lauded for its innovative global fusion cuisine and stellar, intimate service. It is frequently described as one of the best dining experiences in New York, with a strong emphasis on culinary artistry and a welcoming atmosphere.

Pro tip: Amazing food and great customer service! I don’t know why they haven’t gotten a Michelin star.

🍽️Food98

The food is consistently described as outstanding, creative, and flavorful, with a global fusion of influences. Dishes are artfully presented and often described as a culinary journey.

Amazing food and great customer service!

👋Service95

Service is frequently highlighted as stellar, attentive, friendly, and professional, contributing to an intimate and welcoming dining experience.

The staff and service were stellar

Vibe90

The atmosphere is described as intimate, cozy, welcoming, and innovative, with the chef's counter offering a unique view into the kitchen's artistry.

Intimate and cozy with first-rate service

💰Value85

Diners generally find the tasting menu and overall experience to be top-notch and well-worth the price, especially given the creativity and quality.

The value offered was top-notch

📍 432 E 13th St, New York, NY 10009, United States
4.8$$$$New YorkMixed/Fusion
Ideal for
Special occasions and celebrationsDiners seeking innovative culinary experiencesThose who appreciate intimate counter seating
4.

Eulalie

95/100

Eulalie offers an excellent fine dining experience in New York City, characterized by meticulously crafted cuisine, warm and personalized hospitality, and an intimate, elegant atmosphere. It is highly recommended for those seeking a special occasion meal.

Pro tip: This isn’t just dinner—it’s an experience of elegance, warmth, and flawless execution.

🍽️Food98

The cuisine is consistently described as outstanding, creative, and meticulously crafted, with an emphasis on fresh, high-quality ingredients and sophisticated flavor profiles.

Every dish was thoughtfully prepared

👋Service97

Service is frequently highlighted as warm, gracious, enthusiastic, and remarkably hospitable, creating a personalized and memorable guest experience.

Amazing service from start to finish

Vibe92

The atmosphere is well-regarded as cozy, intimate, elegant, and warm, fostering a sense of being a welcomed guest in a private home.

Cozy and beautiful

💰Value85

While the prix fixe menu is noted as a significant investment, many diners feel the overall experience, quality, and portion sizes justify the cost.

Still decent value for money

📍 239 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013, United States
4.9$$$$New YorkFrench
Ideal for
Special occasions and celebrationsDiners seeking an intimate, unpretentious fine dining experienceThose who appreciate attentive, personalized service
5.

Sushi Akira

95/100

Sushi Akira offers an excellent omakase experience in New York City, lauded for its incredibly fresh, high-quality ingredients, creative culinary artistry, and impeccable service. Well-regarded for the value and intimate atmosphere, making it a highly recommended destination for sushi enthusiasts.

Pro tip: Outstanding omakase with fresh ingredients, creative dishes, and attentive service.

🍽️Food98

The sushi and omakase experience are well-regarded for first-rate quality, freshness, and creative preparation, with ingredients often noted as being flown directly from Japan.

All of the sushi was so fresh

👋Service95

Service is frequently described as amazing, incredible, attentive, and friendly, contributing to a pampered and welcoming dining experience.

Amazing service! Thank you for having us

Vibe85

The atmosphere is consistently described as elegant, cozy, intimate, and relaxed, contributing to an enjoyable dining experience.

Cozy minimalist space

💰Value90

Diners feel the omakase experience offers top-notch value, with many noting the high quality of food and service for the price point.

Very reasonable price yet such a high quality

📍 317 E 75th St, New York, NY 10021, United States
4.8$$$New YorkJapanese
Ideal for
Special occasion celebrationsSushi aficionados seeking high qualityIntimate dining experiences
6.

Sushi Aozora

95/100

Sushi Aozora offers an excellent omakase experience, consistently lauded for its incredibly fresh ingredients, masterful preparation, and elegant ambiance. Diners frequently celebrate the value and the thoughtful pacing of the meal, making it a highly recommended destination for sushi connoisseurs.

Pro tip: Outstanding omakase experience with incredibly fresh fish and perfect rice.

🍽️Food98

The omakase experience is well-regarded for its first-rate quality, freshness of ingredients, and masterful preparation, with many diners highlighting unique flavor profiles and artistic presentation.

Every piece of fish was incredibly fresh

👋Service85

Service is generally described as attentive, thoughtful, and professional, though one diner reported a negative encounter with a chef.

Service was attentive and thoughtful

Vibe90

The atmosphere is consistently described as intimate, elegant, refined, and peaceful, making it suitable for special occasions and dates.

Atmosphere is top-notch 10/10

💰Value90

Diners frequently note that the quality of the omakase experience, ingredients, and preparation offers top-notch value for the price.

Top-notch price to quality ratio

📍 15 E 15th St, New York, NY 10003
4.9$$$$New YorkJapanese
Ideal for
Special occasions and datesSushi connoisseurs seeking omakaseDiners appreciating artistic presentation
7.

Omakase Room by Shin

95/100

Chef Shin's omakase in Midtown is the technical argument for why sushi is art: excellent sourcing from Japan, meticulous knife work, presentation that makes you slow down. Service is attentive enough that your glass never empties, but the real draw is watching the chef execute at a level most NYC sushi spots don't attempt. The premium price ($175–$195) makes sense for what you're getting, though tight ingredient sourcing sometimes shows in the constraint of the menu. This is not for vegetarians (it's purely seafood), and it requires a reservation well in advance.

Pro tip: Call and book early—only three seatings nightly, 8 seats total. Ask about seasonal special items when you call; Shin adds things off-menu for diners who show real curiosity about what he's sourcing that week.

🍽️Food98

The omakase experience is well-regarded for its outstanding quality, fresh ingredients, and unique flavor combinations, often described as authentic and artfully prepared.

The quality of the fish was amazing

👋Service95

Service is frequently highlighted as attentive, kind, friendly, and outstanding, contributing significantly to the overall positive dining experience.

Service was kind and attentive

Vibe90

The atmosphere is consistently described as intimate, beautiful, serene, cozy, and elegant, with a relaxed and chill vibe that complements the dining experience.

Beautiful intimate space

💰Value75

While the food and experience are well-regarded, noted the $195 price point for the omakase as an awkward positioning, suggesting a tight control on ingredient costs.

$195 for Omakase is an awkward positioning

📍 145 W 53rd St, New York, NY 10019, United States
4.9$$$$New YorkJapanese
Ideal for
Special occasions like birthdays and anniversariesDiners seeking an authentic Japanese omakase experienceCouples looking for an intimate dining setting
8.

Caviar Cafe

95/100

Caviar Cafe is a highly-regarded establishment in New York's West Village, celebrated for its excellent caviar and fresh ingredients. Well-regarded for the elegant yet warm atmosphere and attentive service, making it a top choice for refined dining and special occasions.

Pro tip: The best caviar i’ve had in the city. Not only is food amazing

🍽️Food98

The food, particularly the caviar and tuna tartare, is well-regarded for its outstanding quality and freshness.

The best caviar i’ve had in the city

👋Service95

Service is frequently described as attentive, warm, professional, and lovely, enhancing the overall dining experience.

Service was attentive without being intrusive

Vibe95

The atmosphere is consistently lauded as elegant, warm, lively, cozy, and welcoming, suitable for special occasions or relaxed indulgence.

The atmosphere feels so warm and lively

💰Value85

While not explicitly detailed, the high quality of ingredients and overall experience suggest good value for a refined dining establishment.

A great spot for a refined lunch

📍 394/A West St, New York, NY 10014
5$$$New YorkSeafood
Ideal for
Caviar enthusiasts — first-rate quality and selectionSpecial occasions — elegant atmosphere and refined diningRefined lunch or indulgence — relaxed yet upscale setting
9.

Taikun Sushi

95/100

Taikun Sushi offers an excellent omakase experience in an intimate setting, lauded for its incredibly fresh, creative sushi and outstanding value. The service is well-regarded, contributing to a sophisticated yet cozy atmosphere that makes it a highly recommended destination for sushi enthusiasts.

Pro tip: Best omakase in the city and the best price.

🍽️Food98

The sushi is well-regarded for its outstanding freshness, quality, and creative preparation, with many diners highlighting specific pieces and flavor combinations.

The fish was fresh and portions are great.

👋Service95

Service is frequently described as first-rate, friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable, contributing significantly to the overall positive dining experience.

Top-notch service and good ambience too.

Vibe90

The intimate, cozy, and sophisticated atmosphere is a significant draw, making it ideal for special occasions and quiet dining.

Very cosy and relaxing vibe!

💰Value95

Diners consistently find the omakase experience to be an top-notch value, with high-quality ingredients and preparation at a reasonable price point.

Best omakase in the city and the best price.

📍 79 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002, United States
4.9$$$New YorkJapanese
Ideal for
Special occasion dining — intimate setting and high-quality foodSushi connoisseurs — top-notch freshness and creative preparationValue seekers — high-quality omakase at a competitive price
10.

Koete Omakase

95/100

Koete Omakase offers an excellent omakase experience in New York City, characterized by incredibly fresh, high-quality ingredients, masterful preparation, and outstanding service. It is widely regarded as a favorite providing outstanding value and a memorable, intimate dining atmosphere.

Pro tip: First-rate food and service in an intimate setting, offering great value.

🍽️Food98

The omakase features remarkably fresh, high-quality ingredients, often sourced directly from Japan, prepared with masterful technique and creative flair. Well-regarded for the delicate flavors and beautiful presentation.

Everything was so fresh

👋Service95

Service is consistently described as top-notch, with staff being friendly, attentive, knowledgeable, and passionate about hospitality, often making guests feel welcomed and at home.

Service was impeccable

Vibe90

The atmosphere is frequently described as intimate, cozy, refined, and upscale, providing a welcome respite from the city's bustle.

Chill intimate atmosphere

💰Value85

While not the cheapest option, the omakase is widely considered to offer top-notch value for the high quality of ingredients, preparation, and overall experience.

Best bang for your buck

📍 1695 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, United States
4.9$$$New YorkJapanese
Ideal for
Special occasions and celebrationsPre-theater diningSushi and seafood aficionados

Can’t decide?

Let DineSpin pick a restaurant for you based on your mood.

Try DineSpin →

More in New York

No paid placements. Independent restaurant rankings.